During my first year of college, I met several girls who were of the depressive type. They wanted to die, they told me, and for a number of reasons: “I’m stupid.” “I’m fat.” “I’m ugly.” “I’m worthless.” “My mother/father/sister/brother despises me.” These were their refrains. I wanted to tell them to shut up, but I held them instead. I buried them with compliments. I said they were smart, beautiful, easy to love. They melted in my arms.
But they, like everything and everyone else, changed. They declared themselves fabulous, strong, and independent. They became too good for everything. Too good for me. They outgrew me, they said. They no longer loved me in that way, they said. Once they found their self-esteem, I was dumped like bad meat.
#
And then there was Elizabeth. One day, out of the blue, she called and said, “Let’s go for a walk.”
We walked and we walked. She asked about my childhood, where I grew up, what life was like. I shared with her the details of my secret love for insects. She quoted Issa:
Oh, don’t mistreat
the fly! He wrings his hands!
He wrings his feet!”
And then she said, “I ate fried mealworms once. They tasted like French fries.”
I fell in love with her, right then and there. Right then and there she became my God.
I told her stories about the other girls, the ones who left me.
“What happened to them?” she asked. “Why don’t they talk to you anymore?”
When I couldn’t answer, she walked me to a pay phone near the public library. I gave her their numbers and a roll of quarters that I’d been saving for laundry. She called those girls, three in total, and left them each the same message: “Kill yourself.”
Then we went to see a movie, some romantic comedy about a lonely virgin and an even lonelier hooker.
When it ended, we returned to my dorm room.
This is where I should tell you what her hair felt like against my chest. How her cheeks flushed and her lips swelled pink and full. But I can’t. To have sex with God is an act so traumatic that you just can’t put it into words. And the mind, because you are unable to deal with such divine pleasure, hides the details in some dusty, sleepy, ghost-town deep within your brain. One day, I was told, when the time is right, those details will burst through my mind like a dagger through a heart.
#
Here lies the dagger.
Hard. Soft. Rough. Firm. Tight. Smooth. Damp. Hot. My hands on her hair. My hands on her waist. My hands on her breasts. Her hands on my hips. Her hands on my face. Our fingers finding secret crevices. Our fingers searching every fold. Our fingers everywhere. Legs intertwined. Elbows bent. Toes flexing. My lips on her lips.
Sunlight (or was it moonlight?) beams through the window, illuminating our skin, blessing our bodies. I have to laugh to keep myself from crying. Her eyes were closed but now they open and peer into mine. Her eyes, deep brown and almond shaped, look at me, study me: she sees me how I am, she sees me how I could have been.
I place a hand over her eyes and hold it there.
She places her hands around my neck and keeps them there.
Like this, we fall asleep.
#
I quit school shortly after finding Elizabeth and went to work at KFC. I became the number one fry cook in town. I took pride in my work. Nothing was better than hearing someone say that my fried chicken was the best they’d ever tasted.
Elizabeth stayed in school and we continued seeing each other. She spent almost every night with me.
We celebrated the new year together — just the two of us in my tiny studio apartment. We decided not to make any resolutions, but I had already made one.
“I love you,” I told her as the bells chimed midnight.
She laughed, but it didn’t hurt.
She took a black Sharpie from my desk. “Give me your hand,” she said. “This is my heart.” And she drew a heart — not a realistic one, of course — but a round and curvy heart on the palm of my hand. In the middle of this heart, she drew a stick figure. “And this is you,” she said.
#
Elizabeth and I ate toast with butter every morning. She’d sleep in late, sometimes even missing class. She’d wear one of my T-shirts, lying in bed without the covers on just so I could see her tan legs and smooth butt. I’d bring her a plate of toast and a cup of black coffee.
“There’s nothing better than toast with butter,” she’d say.
I’d let her lick the crumbs from the corner of my mouth as I answered her questions. She could never hear enough about my childhood, about my past. And I couldn’t get enough of her touch. Unlike my parents, Elizabeth and I were always connected. I knew she would never hurt me.
There really is nothing better than toast with butter. And if you don’t believe me, you can go fuck yourself.
#
In late March, we read about Alexa in the school newspaper. This was the girl I’d met in a literature class during my first semester. She was the one who said her parents never loved her. She was found in a park hanging from a tree. A jump rope was tied around her neck.
A few days later, during the evening news, we learned about Angela. She was the girl with the eating disorder. A roommate had found her emaciated body, curled up and spindly like a dead spider, behind a washing machine in the laundry room.
Lindsey showed up in the desert, sitting in her car. She had bled to death from the deep wounds in her wrists. We heard this from some students who were talking too loudly in the campus bookstore. Lindsey had always believed she was stupid, and even I thought she’d never figure out a way to kill herself.
There was nothing beautiful, nothing fabulous, nothing particularly touching about their deaths. Yet, once we were alone, Elizabeth couldn’t stop talking about them. I held her as she cried.
“These are the girls I called,” she said. “I feel like it’s my fault.”
“Why?” I asked. “Did you kill them?”
Elizabeth pulled away from me. “How can you ask me that?” She wiped her eyes with the sleeve of her coat. She seemed so small, so delicate, sitting on the edge of the bed, shrinking within the thick fabric of her navy blue parka. I wanted to swallow her up, to hide her away from the world, to keep her safe and pure and stuck within my throat so that every time I spoke I would taste her in my mouth.
“Because you’re being silly,” I said. “You have nothing to feel guilty about.”
“But don’t you feel bad?” she asked. “You used to be friends with them.”
“They only cared about themselves. So, no, I don’t feel bad.”
Elizabeth didn’t say anything.
I thought I’d made her angry, and I didn’t want her to be unhappy with me, so I quickly added, “I’m sorry. I just don’t want to talk about it. Come on, come lie down with me.”
“I have to go.” Elizabeth stood up and walked to the door. She placed a hand on the doorknob and paused there for a moment. “I’m tired,” she said. “I need some time to myself. I’ll call you later. Okay?” And then she left.
#
When I fell asleep that night, I dreamed that I was deep-frying maggots. Elizabeth let me scoop spoonful after spoonful of the greasy insects into her mouth. “I love you,” I told her with each serving. “I love you, I love you, I love you.”
#
The next morning, I couldn’t wait to talk to her so I called her as soon as I got dressed. But she didn’t answer and I had to leave a message asking her to please, please, please get in touch with me.
While I waited to hear from her, I couldn’t eat. I didn’t use the bathroom. Hours passed and she never returned my call. I stayed on the couch all day. The telephone, the ringer set to the loudest tone, was on the floor, next to me. I wondered what she could be doing that would keep her from calling me. Once in a while, I’d close my eyes and imagine us together. I found an old shirt of hers that smelled like acacia and lavender and I buried my face in its threadbare material.
Then came the knock on the door.
It was evening and the apartment was now dark except for the glow of the television set. I was cold, so I wrapped a blanket around my shoulders before answering the door. I flipped on the porch light and was disappointed to see two male police officers standing in the doorway. Neither one of them smiled. They asked to enter the apartment.
I was afraid that they were bringing me bad news about Elizabeth.
“Come in,” I said to the police, choking on those two simple words.
They asked me too many questions and showed me graphic pictures of the dead girls. I don’t quite remember what I saw or even what I said. But I do remember asking about Elizabeth. When I asked if she was okay, they looked at each other before reassuring me that she was safe. She wasn’t at her dorm, they said. They could not, would not elaborate.
#
The girls had been dead for quite some time before their bodies were discovered. Missing, then dead, then buried, then dug up and carefully posed. They were found covered in maggots, decomposing, fabulous corpses with rotting smiles.
But none of that matters.
You see, those girls, they didn’t matter to me. They never mattered to anyone. And I can’t feel guilty about what happened to them. They wanted to die. They asked to die. And one way or another they would have killed themselves. In a way, they really did commit suicide.
No, I didn’t kill any of them.
But maybe I did.
No one can argue with the evidence. My lawyer certainly couldn’t. And my mind won’t allow me to remember anything that may have been useful to my defense. There is no dagger, no reason, no resolution. There is nothing except Elizabeth. All that really matters to me now is Elizabeth.
She hasn’t come to visit me. Not yet. But someday she will. You see, this is all a test. I survived the trial, now I only have to pass the test. And when the test ends, Elizabeth will be there, waiting, with her arms open wide and she’ll say, “Let’s go for a walk.” On our walk, I’ll tell her stories about my childhood and she’ll say, “I love you,” and then I will speak in tongues, in a language that only God understands.